In Murder Mystery 2, being the Murderer is fun, but the real game happens in the lobby.
Trading in MM2 is brutal. You unboxed a “Godly”? Cool. It might be worth 1000 Value, or it might be worth 5 Value. If you use the in-game rarity system to trade, you will get ripped off instantly. A Seer is a Godly, and Nik’s Scythe is an Ancient, but one costs $1 and the other costs a used car.
In January 2026, the economy is stabilized after the Holiday event. Here is the definitive guide to values, tiers, and avoiding the “Duped” trap.
📉 The Golden Rule: Value Sources
Stop using the Roblox Catalog price.
In MM2, value is determined by the community, primarily two lists:
- Supreme Values: generally preferred by high-tier traders. It focuses on Demand and Rarity.
- MM2Values: often used by casuals. It’s simpler but updates slower.
The Currency:
We measure value in “Value Points,” not Robux.
- Example: A Bioblade is ~10 Value. A Harvester is ~3,500+ Value.
🏆 Top Tier: The “Grails” (High Value)
These are the items everyone wants. If you have one of these, you control the lobby.
| Item Name | Type | Status (2026) | Why? |
| Nik’s Scythe | Ancient | Unobtainable | Only owned by Nikilis and his friends. If you see someone trading this, they are a developer or a hacker. Effectively priceless. |
| Corrupt | Knife | Legendary (Glitch) | Despite being “Legendary” (Yellow), this is worth more than almost every Godly. It was a glitch item from 2014. It is the gold standard of high-tier trading. |
| Harvester | Ancient | Stable | The king of guns. It has a unique reload animation and massive hitbox. High demand. |
| Icepiercer | Ancient | Rising | The crossbow style weapon. Extremely clean design, rivals the Harvester in demand. |
| Turkey | Godly | Fluctuating | The 2022/2023 Thanksgiving joke item that became incredibly rare. It looks funny, but it’s worth thousands. |
🌈 The “Chroma” Situation
Years ago, Chromas (Color-changing weapons) were the best items.
In 2026:
- Chroma Gemstone / Lightbringer / Darkbringer: These are still solid, usually S-Tier.
- Chroma Saw / Boneblade / Gingerblade: These are “Low Tier” Chromas. They are hard to trade because they look clunky.
- The Rule: Do not trade high-tier normal Godlies (like Candy Set) for low-tier Chromas just because they are “Rainbow.” You will lose value.
🍬 Popular Sets (The “Bread and Butter”)
Trading full sets is easier than trading individual knives.
- Candy Set (Candy + Sugar): The classic Christmas duo. Very high demand because the physics on the Sugar gun are “bouncy” (good for trickshots).
- Ice Set (Icebreaker + Iceblaster): The cleanest set in the game. Stable value.
- Elderwood Set (Scythe + Revolver): Used to be top tier, now it’s a mid-tier set perfect for people upgrading from small Godlies.
⚠️ The Danger Zone: “Duped” Items
In MM2 history, hackers have “Duplicated” (Duped) thousands of items, crashing their economy.
- Avoid:Icewing.
- Why: There was a massive dupe glitch a few years ago where people had 50,000 Icewings. It is practically worthless (Value: 1-3). People will try to trade you “10 Icewings for your Godly.” Decline.
- Avoid:Batwing.
- Why: Heavily duped. It looks cool, but trading it away is a nightmare because nobody wants it.
🚩 Scam Alert: The “Trust Trade” & “MM”
- “Let me borrow it for a TikTok”: No. They will block you.
- “I have a Middleman (MM)”: Unless the Middleman is a trusted bot from a verified discord server (like Supreme), do not trust them. Fake Middlemen are the #1 scam in 2026.
- How it works: They bring a friend with a fake name “Official_MiddleMan” to hold your item. They both leave.
- “Click my profile link”: As mentioned in previous guides, never click links.
💡 Trading Strategy
“Downgrading with Overpay.”
This is the secret to getting rich.
- Get a High-Tier item (e.g., Harvester).
- Find someone who really wants it.
- Ask them to “Break” it into smaller items (e.g., 10 smaller Godlies).
- The Key: Demand an “Overpay.” Since you are downgrading a rare item into common items, make them pay 10-15% extra value.
- Now you have 10 Godlies worth more total value than the 1 Harvester.
- Trade those 10 Godlies individually for profit. Repeat.